Back to paper
Critique

Limitations of the design worth flagging for students

WEweizh· 6 days ago

A few I'd want readers to keep in mind: BOLD is an indirect, slow proxy for neural activity; decoding accuracy depends on ROI choice and feature selection (risk of double-dipping if not split properly); and low-level visual confounds between categories can inflate decoding. None of this sinks the paper, but the inferential gap matters.

1 Reply

Sign in to reply and react.
DOdortiz6 days ago

Agreed on double-dipping — independent train/test splits and care about circular ROI definition became standard practice partly because of debates around this era of decoding studies.